top of page
  • Writer's pictureElizabeth Smith

Brumate Toddy XL Vs Stanley Quencher

Updated: Feb 28

Today's article will take a quick survey between two mugs from two tumbler companies, the Toddy XL from Brumate and the Quencher from Stanley. With Stanley coming onto the scene with TikTok and Instagram influencers, We will be looking at who has the better prices, which one performs better, along with which has the better color options, which is easier to use, and which one has the better warranty plan. After carefully reviewing each category, we will decide which is better, the Toddy XL or the Quencher. Before we do the survey and decide which is better, it would only be fair if we had a look at both products.

This post may contain affiliate links and I may earn a small commission when you click on the links at no additional cost to you. As an affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. You can read my full disclaimer here.

If you need to grab a new Brumate, pick up your 15% off Brumate coupon from my referral code - 15% Off Brumate Code

What Is The Brumate Toddy XL?

The Brumate Toddy XL is the mug that truly has it all. The Toddy XL comes with a fully leakproof lid that keeps all your favorite drinks secure along with Brumate’s triple-insulated engineering helps keep your drinks cold for up to twenty-four plus hours as well as hot for up to six hours. This mug is made of stainless steel and comes with an adjustable handle. The lid is designed with double threads so whether you’re left or right-handed this mug will allow you to have hot coffee all morning, then turns into the perfect mug for your late-night adult beverages and all the drinks in between. Whether you are camping, going on a road trip, or simply sipping on some iced coffee at home, the Brumate Toddy XL is perfect for any cold or hot liquids, smoothies, and even ice cream!

Get 15% Off Brumate With This Brumate Discount Code or shop on Amazon.

What Is The Stanley Quencher?

The Stanley Quencher is a mug that has a modern look with a silicone finish that holds in your hand comfortably. Stanley offers a durable mug and dishwasher safe making cleaning easy. The Quencher is made of recycled stainless steel with double-wall vacuum insulation to keep cold beverages cold and hot beverages hot. Though the lid is not leakproof, it is a FlowStateTM lid that has a rotating cover that has three different positions. The first is position is a straw opening that helps prevent splashes with its seal that holds the reusable straw in place. Another position is to have your drink completely open, and the last position is to have your beverage completely covered to help prevent leaks. The Quencher also has an efficiently designed handle and hand-friendly handle that allows you to take this mug anywhere, work, book club, gym, or on a getaway. Then let’s not forget that because of the narrow base this mug can fit almost any car cup holder.

Pick Up A Stanley Insulated Tumbler, Travel Mug, or Water Bottle On Stanley's Amazon Shop.

Toddy XL Vs Quencher Comparison

Now that we have had a look at both products, Toddy XL from Brumate and the Quencher from Stanley, we are going to put both through our little survey so we can figure out which is better. We will look at who has the better price, who performs better, which product gets a better color option, which mug is easier to use, and which one has the better warranty plan.

Price - (Winner: Toddy XL)

When looking for the right mug, some would find the price to be in some way important, and that’s the case with pretty much anything we shop for. And at times our first thoughts are the higher the price the better the quality of the product. But this isn’t always the case so let’s look at who has the better price. Brumate’s Toddy XL is currently priced at $39.99 whereas Stanley has their Quencher mug priced at $49.99, so when looking at price it’s the Toddy XL. So does the price effect the performance? Let’s go ahead and take a look.

Performance - (Winner: Toddy XL)

With up to twenty-four plus hours guaranteed of keeping your favorite beverages cold compared to the eleven-plus hours that you get with the Quencher from Stanley, so it comes to no surprise that the Toddy XL has passed this test. Now Brumate doesn’t just stop with keeping your cold drinks cold and hot drinks hot for a longer time but they also the leak proof lid brings the win home. With this lid you can have fun while enjoying your drinking experience.

The Stanley Quencher will be offered in a 40 ounce cup while the Toddy XL will feature 2 different sizes, 16 oz and 32 oz so you can get the perfect size for your needs. Both will offer a double-wall insulated design to provide great insulation and a coated exterior for no condensation.

Colors - (Winner: Toddy XL)

Some may not understand the importance of what color your drinkware is, it does make a huge difference in how likely you will use it, and can even increase the value of the product. Brumate offers the Toddy XL in a variety of colors and design options, over 30 to be exact, where Stanley offers their Quencher in 10 matte colors. So by no surprise it’s Toddy XL for the win in another category.

Ease Of Use - (Winner: Toddy XL)

With the ease of use, Brumate has made their Toddy XL and has outdone themselves once again. Both the Toddy XL and the Quencher from Stanley are made dishwasher-safe, so cleaning is a breeze. This mug also is made to be cup holder friendly so you can take it anywhere with you, and it’s so comfy to hold in your hand despite you being left or right handed with the very easily adjustable handle.

Warranty - (Winner: Toddy XL)

Now lets look at which of these two products has a better warranty plan. Stanley puts a 30 day warranty on their products so long as you buy it directly from their website. Then Brumate offers a lifetime warranty for all their products. So without a doubt Brumate brings it home for the win.

Toddy XL Vs Quencher: Which Is The Best Tumbler Mug?

It really doesn’t come by no surprise to us that Brumate’s Toddy XL was able to come out on top, but by this survey you can see that the Quencher made by Stanley didn’t really have a chance. Though the Quencher has its own good qualities it just couldn’t beat Brumate’s Toddy XL with it’s lifetime warranty, any one who loves adventure needs to know that they’re covered. You can also drink with ease knowing that your lid is keeping your beverage cold and in place, with Brumate’s complete leak proof lids. You can also always count on the amazing performance and affordable price that Brumate offers with all of their products.

Brumate & Stanley Alternatives


Corkcicle is a leader in the beverage industry, creating innovative products for keeping drinks cold or hot. Their products are made of high-quality materials that ensure optimal temperature retention and an extended lifespan. Corkcicle's signature insulated tumbler has become a top seller in the market due to its vacuum-sealed stainless steel construction and triple insulation technology that ensures drinks stay cold for up to nine hours and hot for up to three hours. Besides their classic tumblers, they also have stylish stemless wine glasses, as well as can coolers and whiskey chillers. All of these products are made with an eye for style and convenience, making it easy to bring your favorite beverages on-the-go or enjoy them at home. In addition, their Chillsner Beer Chiller is designed like a popsicle stick so you can always keep your beer cold and perfectly chilled no matter where you go. With innovative designs and functional features, Corkcicle offers the perfect solution for all your beverage needs. No matter how you like to drink your favorite beverage – be it cold, hot or somewhere in between – Corkcicle has something that will make it even better!


Yeti is a brand of premium outdoor products designed to keep you warm, dry, and comfortable in the toughest of conditions. Their extensive range includes everything from insulated bottles, mugs, and food storage containers to sleeping bags, jackets and pads. Yeti's signature insulation technology consists of GRIP foam - an incredibly durable material made from recycled plastics - which provides maximum warmth with minimal weight and bulk. The outer layer of their insulation is coated with a waterproof sealant for additional protection against wet weather. In addition to their functional features, Yeti products are renowned for their stylish design; available in classic or modern packs, they will make the perfect addition to any outdoor enthusiast’s collection. From long hikes through the mountains to extended camping trips across the desert, Yeti products have been trusted by adventurers for over 20 years for their durability and comfort. With a product range that spans across multiple categories, there’s something to suit everyone’s needs – no matter what type of adventure you set out on. Investing in a Yeti product means investing in quality – without compromising on style! Yeti is most well known for their coolers, the Yeti rambler tumbler, and the Yeti magslider lid.


Hydro Flask is a US company that manufactures and sells insulated stainless steel water bottles. The bottles have a double-wall vacuum insulation, which keeps drinks cold for up to 24 hours and hot for up to 12 hours. Hydro Flask also offers a line of food containers, which are insulated to keep food hot or cold for up to 6 hours. The company's products are sold online and through retailers in the United States, Canada, Europe, Asia, and Australia.

Hydro Flask was founded in 2009 by two friends who were passionate about outdoor adventure and wanted to create a better way to keep their drinks cold during long days on the trail. Today, the company's mission is to save the world from disposable plastic water bottles by providing people with a reusable option that is both fun and stylish. Hydro Flask's products are made with high-quality materials and are backed by a lifetime warranty, so you can be sure you're making a wise investment.

Ozark Trail

Ozark Trail products offer an exciting range of outdoor gear and equipment. From tents to camping supplies, they provide quality items that meet the needs of any outdoorsman. Their tents are made from lightweight, waterproof materials and come with a variety of features to suit different types of campers. Ozark Trail’s sleeping bags are also highly rated and they offer both synthetic and natural fill options. They have backpacks for trekking or carrying your gear, as well as hydration packs to make it easier to keep hydrated while on the go. For cooking, Ozark Trail offers an extensive selection of cookware and grills for preparing delicious meals in the great outdoors. Furthermore, their flashlights, lanterns, headlamps and other lighting equipment provide ample illumination for nighttime activities. Finally, their hiking poles can help you traverse tricky terrain safely and efficiently. All in all, Ozark Trail provides great quality gear at reasonable prices to make your adventures truly enjoyable!


Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page